Solomon Zeitlin - Dead Sea Scrolls are not so ancient

Steven Avery

Administrator
Solomon Zeitman (1892-1976)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon_Zeitlin

JSTOR -

Bar Kokba and Bar Kozeba (1952)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1452913

This next one I read

The Fiction of the Recent Discoveries near the Dead Sea (1953)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1452866

The Newly Discovered Bar Kokeba Letters (1954)
Isaiah Sonne
https://www.jstor.org/stable/3622151

The Antiquity of the Hebrew Scrolls and the Piltdown Hoax (1954)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1453142

The Medieval Mind and the Theological Speculation on the Dead Sea Scrolls (1958)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1453165

More Literature on the Dead Sea Scrolls: More Pseudo-Scholarship (1959)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1453081

Review: The Fallacy of the Antiquity of the Hebrew Scrolls Once More Exposed (1962)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1453640

Herod: A Malevolent Maniac (1963)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1453457

THE EPISTLE OF BARNABAS AND THE FINAL REBUILDING OF THE TEMPLE
John J. Gunther
https://www.jstor.org/stable/24656876

Solomon Zeitlin (May 28, 1886-December 28, 1976) (1978)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/3622306

REVIEW OF ARTICLES on JSTOR
https://www.jstor.org/stable/24669608


1682973296539.png
 
Last edited:

Steven Avery

Administrator
More Solomon Zeitlin

http://gnosis.org/library/dss/dss_timeline.htm
French scholar, André Dupont-Sommer, publishes his Preliminary Views on the Dead Sea Manuscripts, identifying them as the product of Essenes & suggesting that they were composed at the still unexcavated site of Khirbet Qumran.
-- Skeptical historian, Solomon Zeitlin, challenges "The Alleged Antiquity of the Scrolls" & claims they were forgeries (Jewish Quarterly Review 40-41).
-- W. F. Albright engages Zeitlin in public debate in Philadelphia presenting persuasive arguments for the authenticity of the scrolls based on external evidence .
-- Trevor publishes photos of Isaiah scroll & a commentary on Habakkuk (1QpHab).

The Dead Sea Scrolls and Contemporary Culture -(2011) -
https://books.google.com/books?id=FSnLk6MTPfMC&pg=PA628
https://books.google.com/books?id=FSnLk6MTPfMC&pg=PA631
Ellis Rivkin follows ZS on Medieval provenance



1682973460133.png
 
Last edited:

Steven Avery

Administrator
why was solomon zeitlin skeptical of the authenticity of the DSS? And what was the Chinese connection?

====================

Solomon Zeitlin’s Skepticism
The late Dr. Solomon Zeitlin (1892–1976), a distinguished professor of Rabbinic Literature at Dropsie College, was the most prominent academic voice to argue that the Dead Sea Scrolls (DSS) were a modern or medieval hoax rather than authentic Second Temple documents. [1, 2]
His skepticism was rooted in "internal evidence" based on his profound, multilingual memory of primary Rabbinic and historical literature: [1, 2]
  • Medieval Vocabulary & Spelling: Zeitlin argued that the spelling of specific Hebrew words, terms, and punctuation marks used in the scrolls did not appear in Jewish texts until the Middle Ages. [1]
  • Anachronistic Jewish Laws: He claimed the scrolls referenced specific Jewish legal traditions (halachah) and religious laws that were not in vogue during the pre-Christian era but were enacted centuries later. [1]
  • The Karaite Theory: Zeitlin strongly believed the texts were medieval Karaite documents—writings from a literalist Jewish sect that emerged around the 8th century CE—that had been hidden away or planted in the caves. [1 , 2]
  • Suspicion of Provenance: Plagued by a "hermeneutics of suspicion," Zeitlin found the story of a wandering Bedouin shepherd finding priceless ancient scrolls in jars too similar to old, recurring manuscript discovery myths. He suspected modern forgery or old manuscripts being passed off as ancient to fulfill market demand. [1, 2, 3, 4]
While modern paleography, archaeology, and Carbon-14 dating eventually soundly rejected Zeitlin's views, his fierce, decades-long critiques in the Jewish Quarterly Review forced early scroll scholars to be much more rigorous in verifying their findings. [1, 2, 3]



The "Chinese Connection"
The "Chinese connection" is an entirely separate, fringe theory that emerged decades later to challenge the standard timeline and origin of the scrolls, but it often overlaps in circles discussing alternative or skepticism-driven DSS theories. [1, 2]
Propounded primarily by independent researcher Neil Altman and supported by linguist Victor Mair, the theory suggests direct ancient or medieval contact between the Qumran community (or later scroll handlers) and China: [1, 2]
    • Cryptic Margin Signs: In 1991, Altman wrote that several previously undeciphered markings and symbols written in the margins of major scrolls (such as the Great Isaiah Scroll and the Habakkuk Commentary) were actually ancient Chinese characters. [1]
    • The "Moshe Leah" Scroll: The theory gained traction among alternative-history circles after claims emerged regarding a text known as the "Moshe Leah Scroll" allegedly tied to China, which proponents used to argue that the scrolls may have originated much further East or much later than the standard 250 BCE–70 CE timeline. [1]
How they intersect: While Solomon Zeitlin did not write about China himself (as he passed away in 1976), modern skeptics who doubt the conventional Qumran narrative still quote Zeitlin's text-critical arguments alongside Altman and Mair's Chinese character hypotheses to argue that mainstream archaeology has misdated or misattributed the true history of the scrolls. Mainstream scholarship, however, views these margin marks as scribal shorthand, sectarian symbols, or stylized Greek characters rather than Chinese script. [1, 2]
If you are exploring the early academic battles over the scrolls, would you like to know more about W.F. Albright's public debates with Zeitlin, or how Carbon-14 dating eventually disproved the medieval theories? [1, 2, 3]


  • ResearchGate

    New Evidence on the Shapira Deuteronomy Fragments
    Discover the world's research identical circumstances, some scholars made the obvious inference: The Dead Sea Scrolls, too, were a...



  • The New York Times

    A Scholar Who jousts With the Skepstics - The New York Times
    Feb 13, 1972 — Profile: Solomon Zeitlin, rabbinics and history professor at Dropsie University for 55 years without missing a class; approaching ...



  • Jewish Telegraphic Agency

    Prof. Zeitlin Disputes Value of Dead Sea Scrolls for Judaism
    Prof. Zeitlin Disputes Value of Dead Sea Scrolls for Judaism February 22, 1956 The Dead Sea Scrolls “have no value for Judaism or ...
 
Last edited:
Top