Autographa - additional scholarship help - (includes summary from Gennadius - Pasquale Pinto - compare to Benvenuto)

Steven Avery

Administrator
List from Benvenuto

Aldo Corcella

Pasquale Massimo Pinto

Alessandra Bucossi theological writings cited.

Maria Georgopoulou, director Gennadius Library in Athens,

Irini Solomonidi, librarian Gennadius, expert guides in consulting rare materials by Simonidis,
Athens at the American School of Classical Studies.

library of the monastery of Aghios Panteleimon, on Mount Athos, and of its monk librarian.
 
Last edited:

Steven Avery

Administrator
p. 193
Luciano Canfora - compare to Travel Report of Lycourgas

p. 194
artificial minuscule script, which perhaps seeks to be inspired by traditional Byzantine scripts and which is very conspicuously characterized by the recurring presence of terminal thickenings in the form of a bubble.

4. Le altre opere litografate
La fantasmagorica messe di appunti, trascrizioni, disegni, brogliacci, escerti, etc. che ii presunto scambio epistolare con Callinico dispiega non si limita, peraltro, al solo volume degli A1TóyQapa: l'intero in-sieme delle opere litografate offre una serie di materiali ancora inesplo-rati di cui potrebbe essere interessante indagare, internamente, le rela-zioni reciproche, nonché le connessioni con ii resto dell'opera del falsa-rio. Presentiamo, per ora, di seguito una sommaria descrizione dei con-tenuti notevoli delle altre quattro opere litografate di Simonidis

4. The other lithographed works The phantasmagorical mass of notes, transcriptions, drawings, rough drafts, extracts, etc. that the alleged exchange of letters with Callinicus displays is not limited, however, to the volume of the A1TóyQapa: the entire set of lithographed works offers a series of still unexplored materials whose reciprocal relations could be interesting to investigate internally, as well as the connections with the rest of the forger's work. For now, we present below a summary description of the notable contents of the other four lithographed works by Simonidis

preserved in the volumes currently in Athens at the Gennadius Library BB 1226.68, BB 1226.68 copy 2, and BB 1226.69', in Oxford, Bodleian Library, Byw 1.6.4, and Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale de France J-6227. Fragments are also found in ms. 537 of the Patriarchal Library of Alexandria. The surviving volumes contain:

(1) presumed lithographic copy of a first letter of Simonidis to Callinicus, from Alexandria 11-27 August 1852, on Egyptological and Orientalist subjects, contains - it is perhaps useful to underline - mentions and extracts from the false Uranus of Simonidis [

(2) a second letter, still on an Egyptological subject, is addressed by Simonidis to Callinicus, from Alexandria, 30 August 1852;

(3) a third letter, addressed to Callinicus by Simonidis from Sinai on 16 April 1852, opens with notes on Nonnus of Panopolis, continues with a quotation from Dionigi on Theopompus, with the reproduction and transcription of three epigraphs, mentioning Theopompus, procured for the forger by Nicolaus Melissenus; Simonidis, moreover, reproduces and transcribes the text of a papyrus, which he says was found in the library of St. Catherine of Sinai; the letter ends with the lithographic reproduction and transcription of a sepulchral epigraph in presumed Lycian characters. (should mention history of St. Catherine's) (also they should be informed of the Rhodes copy with the 1854 dedication)

And more letters, maybe 5 total
 
Last edited:

Steven Avery

Administrator
Benvenuto
p. 10-11
While the controversy over the Sinaiticus of the Bible was raging in the English press and The Guardian was
hosting, on several occasions, the interventions of the mysterious hieromonk Callinicus, alleged editor of the
Autographa and other lithographed works, who claimed to be an eyewitness to the Simonidic forgery of the
venerable "relic" of Sinai, Robert Charles Ransome (1830-1886), probably already at the beginning of July
1863, must have instructed, on behalf of Hodgkin, his man in Odessa, the agent Otto Wahl, to investigate
the matter, if on 12 July the latter wrote to Ransome himself, as we learn on f. 256 ff. of the first volume of
the Additional 42502
: <<Your private matter has my best attention, but I am afraid I shall have to write to
Moscow for The Book. The same was privately printed here but all spare copies used as waste paper but
perhaps I shall be able to get a copy from some of the Greek Clergy>>.
 
Last edited:

Steven Avery

Administrator
Where is this published?

CARM

A few more things to note.

Otto Wahl writing to Robert Charles Ransome dated July 12th 1863 (Folio 256 ff., Volume 1, Additional 42502)
"...our private matter [i.e. Hodgkin's secret investigation of Simonides' fake travel stories] has my best attention, but I am afraid I shall have to write to Moscow for The [Autographa?] Book. The same was privately printed here but all [note readers "ALL"] spare copies used as waste paper, but perhaps [note readers "but perhaps"] I shall be able to get a copy from some of the Greek Clergy..."
 

Steven Avery

Administrator
PBF

CARM

One area where the Carmelo Nicolo Benvenuto paper is strong is in confirming the lithographer A. Braun in Odessa in the 1850s (the shop opened in 1829). One book is emphasized that has lots of lithography from the publisher.
Guide du voyageur en Crimée (Odessa, 1834)
Charles Henri Montandon
https://books.google.com/books?id=AEuKcDIlDPcC&pg=PA273
Carmelo writes:
the lithographs (maps, graphs, illustrations and drawings) printed in the volume all show the caption "Litho. by A. Braun in Odessa".

1765109898972.png

Carmelo discusses the Hodgkin-Otto Wahl of Odessa ("Wahl worked in Odessa on behalf of Ransome & Sims of Ipswich") communications which go into the lithography inquiry.

Our translation work on these studies is still in an early, rough stage. We are working with Italian, Greek and Russian. So far it appears to be information that supports the 1853-54 authenticity of the Autographa, which is not the goal of the Carmelo paper :).

However, the studies are still preliminary.
This paper has added new dimensions to the inquiries.
 
Top